We would like to thank each and every person who passes through our doors. Every day we see new faces that we have never met. We also have regulars that we know on a first name basis, and we honestly miss them if they don't show up on time. Our coffee counter is just like those you might remember from decades ago, and the many stories that are passed along, it has built our reputation as the finest meeting spot in Mansfield, Ohio. We accommodate groups of all sizes, and accept reservations for meetings, parties, family dinners, and others who want to plan get-togeter activities in a friendly, relaxed atmosphere.
As evidence by our menu, The Coney Island Inn offers you the best overall value for your dining dollars with all-day breakfast specials, home-cooked lunch specials, and a daily featured soup and sandwich deal. Our regular menu offers our permanent selections of breakfast, lunch and dinner. Some of our specialties include our world-famous coney sauce (available for carry-out in pints or quarts!), our award-winning chili, home-made meat and marinara sauces, sweet potato pancakes and homemade rice pudding.